AWK SURVIVOR ADVOCATE ATTORNEYS

School Abuse Survivors Fight Back in Maryland’s Top Court

White Plains, NY — The Maryland Supreme Court has agreed to hear a landmark case that could determine whether survivors of childhood sexual abuse in public schools — abused before July 1971 — have any right to justice at all under the state's Child Victims Act.

For survivors, advocates, and attorneys fighting institutional abuse, the outcome of Board of Education for Wicomico County v. Rhonda B. Sturm will send a clear message about who this state believes deserves accountability.

The Case: One Survivor, One Critical Question

Rhonda Sturm was a child during the 1970–71 school year in Wicomico County, Maryland. Decades later, she came forward with allegations of abuse — exactly the kind of delayed disclosure that the Maryland Child Victims Act of 2023 was designed to address. The CVA eliminated the statute of limitations for civil claims of childhood sexual abuse against institutions, finally giving survivors the legal footing to be heard.

The Wicomico County Board of Education responded not with accountability, but with a motion to dismiss — arguing that because school boards had complete immunity from lawsuits prior to July 1971, Sturm never had a claim to begin with, and therefore the CVA's look-back window cannot "revive" it. The board also argued it has no insurance available for pre-1971 claims, meaning any payment would come from educational funds.

A Wicomico County Circuit Court judge denied that motion to dismiss in September 2025. The Maryland Appellate Court dismissed the board's appeal. Now the state's highest court has stepped in — and agreed to hear the case at what co-counsel Robert Jenner described as "rocket-docket speed".

AWK Survivor Advocates Attorney Hillary Nappi: "The Look-Back Window Looked Back"

AWK Survivor Advocates attorney Hillary Nappi, who represents Rhonda Sturm alongside Baltimore-based co-counsel Robert Jenner, has been unequivocal about what the law requires.

"The precedent makes very clear that the look-back window looked back," Nappi said. "On its face, this is what it says."

Nappi argues that the Wicomico County Board of Education is attempting to "disregard the legislature" — and that the Child Victims Act "fully intended for survivors to collect damages". This is not a technical legal dispute about procedural history. It is a question of whether public institutions can use their former immunity as a permanent shield, even when the legislature has explicitly acted to remove it.

For Sturm and the many survivors in her position, this case is not abstract. It is the difference between acknowledgment and erasure.

What the Board's Argument Really Says About Priorities

The Wicomico County Board of Education framed its certiorari petition around the concern that paying abuse survivors would divert funds from today's students. That framing deserves scrutiny.

The abuse happened in a school. It was enabled by the same institution now claiming it cannot afford accountability. Arguing that educational funds must be protected from abuse claims is not a neutral fiscal position — it is a choice to prioritize institutional finances over the survivors those institutions failed.

Maryland already faces an estimated $60 billion in potential liability from thousands of CVA claims filed against state agencies, public schools, foster care systems, and government institutions. Rather than set aside funds or develop a payment plan, the state has so far offered no public strategy for meeting that obligation. The 2025 amendment to the CVA cut damages caps for government defendants from $890,000 to $400,000 per claimant — a more-than-50% reduction — while private institutions saw caps cut from $1.5 million to $700,000. Survivors filed claims in good faith under the original law; the legislature then moved the goalposts mid-process.

Why This Case Matters Beyond Maryland

The Sturm case raises a question that will resonate in every state with a Child Victims Act or similar look-back window: Can institutions that were previously immune use that prior immunity to permanently escape accountability, even after the legislature votes to end it?

If the Maryland Supreme Court sides with the school board, it could effectively create a two-tiered system — where survivors of private institutional abuse (churches, civic organizations) can recover, but survivors of abuse in public schools cannot, simply because of an administrative legal technicality that predates most survivors' ability to come forward. That outcome would undermine the entire purpose of the CVA and signal to survivors across the country that legislative reform can be undone by the very institutions it was meant to hold accountable.

What Survivors Need to Know Right Now

If you or someone you know experienced childhood sexual abuse in a Maryland public school, government facility, or any institution — regardless of when it occurred — you may still have legal options. The law is actively evolving, and the outcome of the Sturm case will directly affect what remedies are available.

Key facts to know:

  • Maryland's Child Victims Act (2023) eliminated the statute of limitations for civil child sexual abuse claims against institutions
  • The 2025 CVA amendment reduced damages caps for claims filed on or after June 1, 2025, making it critical to act promptly
  • Public school boards, state agencies, and government entities are covered — but their liability is being actively contested in court
  • The Maryland Supreme Court's ruling in Sturm could expand or restrict survivors' rights — making skilled legal representation essential right now

AWK Survivor Advocates

The Sturm case is being watched by survivors, advocates, and legal experts across the country. AWK Survivor Advocates attorney Hillary Nappi is on the front lines of this fight — arguing that the law means what it says, and that no institution gets to rewrite a survivor's rights.

If you are a survivor of childhood sexual abuse by a teacher, school employee, clergy member, or anyone in a position of institutional trust, do not wait. The window for maximum recovery may be narrowing.

Contact AWK Survivor Advocates today for a free, confidential consultation.
Visit us at

awk-saa.com

to learn more about your rights under the Maryland Child Victims Act.

Read the original reporting by Ian Round in The Daily Record:

MD Supreme Court to Hear Case on Public School Districts' Child Victims Act Liability

Survivors fought for this law. AWK Survivor Advocates is here to make sure it works for them.